Top 5 Craziest Elbaf Theories from Reddit That Might Actually Be True! (One Piece)

One Piece has officially entered its endgame, and all eyes are turning toward the giant island of Elbaf — the land of warriors, Norse myths, and possibly the final clash between the Straw Hats and the World Government. As fans eagerly await new chapters, Reddit has become a goldmine of wild, yet shockingly plausible theories.

In this blog post, we're diving deep into the top 5 Elbaf theories from Reddit that are blowing minds and stirring up intense debate in the One Piece community.

Why Elbaf Is So Important in One Piece

Before jumping into the theories, let's set the stage. Elbaf has been teased since the Little Garden arc. It’s the homeland of giants like Dorry, Brogy, and Hajrudin. But more importantly, Elbaf may be tied to:

• The Void Century

• JoyBoy’s legacy

• Sun God Nika’s true purpose

• The origin of Devil Fruits

• Uranus or another Ancient Weapon

With that in mind, let’s break down five of the most compelling Reddit theories around Elbaf that might just end up being canon.

1. Imu Was One of the 20 Monarchs — And Never Sat on the Throne

⭐ Theory by u/OneTruthPirate | Upvoted over 3.5k times

This theory speculates that Imu was originally one of the 20 kings who founded the World Government 800 years ago. When the other monarchs placed their weapons in front of the Empty Throne to symbolize equality, Imu didn’t — because he never intended to share power.

Over time, Imu used the Ope-Ope no Mi to gain immortality and potentially consumed a Mythical Zoan Devil Fruit. This immense power allowed him to conquer the others behind the scenes, seize control of Uranus, and form the mysterious Five Elders (Gorosei) to act as public figureheads, hiding the truth of his rule.

Elbaf Connection:

The giants value honor and open battle. If the Straw Hats make it to Elbaf, it’s possible they will uncover the truth of the Void Century, and the dishonorable betrayal by Imu. This could be the spark that unites Elbaf against the World Government in the final war.

2. The One Piece Is a Devil Fruit Only Nika Can Use

⭐ Theory by u/NikaFuture | Upvoted over 5.1k times

One of the most mind-blowing theories suggests that the One Piece is not a treasure, but a very specific Devil Fruit that can only be consumed by the user of the Human-Human Fruit, Model: Nika — i.e., Luffy.

This explains why Joy Boy failed — he didn’t have the Nika fruit user in his time — but left behind a weapon or fruit that, when used with Nika’s awakened form, could end Imu’s immortality.

This theory also connects to the idea of Luffy gaining a second Devil Fruit, like Blackbeard, to balance the scales in the final war.

Elbaf Connection:

The giants already revere Sun God Nika. If JoyBoy left the "One Piece" in Elbaf, it would make perfect sense that the Giants guard it unknowingly — until the return of Nika in Luffy. This could also explain why Vegapunk’s theory of inherited will and laughter ties into Elbaf's traditions.

3. Devil Fruits Were Created to Fight Imu’s Demonic Power

⭐ Theory by u/DevilFruitTruth | Upvoted 4.2k times

This theory posits that Devil Fruits were engineered long ago as a weapon against Imu, whose powers are so unnatural and powerful they seem demonic. Consider the term “Devil” in Devil Fruit — a hint, perhaps?

The awakening of these fruits also gives off white smoke from the user’s body — possibly a divine power in contrast to Imu’s darkness. The SMILE fruits are failed attempts to replicate Nika’s powers — hence why users can’t stop laughing uncontrollably, mimicking Nika's joy.

Elbaf Connection:

If Devil Fruits are weapons of rebellion, Elbaf may be the last place where their true origin is known. Could the giants be the last culture to remember the truth? Vegapunk hinted that Elbaf holds ancient knowledge — maybe even the blueprint of Devil Fruits themselves.

4. Prime Garp, Dragon, and Luffy Will Unite on Elbaf

⭐ Theory by u/MarineLegend | Upvoted 3.1k times

After the chilling battle between Garp and Aokiji, many believe Garp is frozen but not dead. This Redditor theorizes that once the Straw Hats reach Elbaf, Bonney might revert Garp back to his prime form using her age powers.

Imagine this alliance:

• Prime Garp backed by SWORD and Kuzan

• Dragon with the Revolutionary Army

• Luffy with the Straw Hat Grand Fleet

It would be an epic three-generation strike force against the World Government.

Elbaf Connection:

Elbaf could be the rallying point for the final war, similar to how Marineford was for Ace’s rescue. The Straw Hat Fleet, the Revolutionaries, the remnants of the Marines, and the Giants might all converge here to launch the last battle against Imu and the Gorosei.

5. Luffy, Sanji, and Chopper Are Ticking Time Bombs

⭐ Theory by u/DFWatcher | Upvoted 2.7k times

This theory explores the hidden costs of power. Each of these three Straw Hats has potential personality-breaking side effects:

• Luffy’s Nika form could eventually take over his personality, especially since Vegapunk noted that Zoan awakenings can affect the user’s mind.

• Sanji might become a cold-blooded killer if his Germa genes fully awaken.

• Chopper, with another Rumble Ball or awakened form, could lose control entirely and become a berserker beast.

What’s chilling is that all three changes would symbolize a “loss of humanity” — turning the very heroes of the story into monsters.

Elbaf Connection:

If these transformations happen, Elbaf might be the perfect place to face them. It’s a land where might makes right, and the crew may have to face their inner demons before they can battle the real ones.

Why These Theories Matter

These five theories aren't just fan fiction — they’re deeply connected to the core mysteries of One Piece:

• What happened in the Void Century?

• Who is Imu?

• What exactly is the One Piece?

• Are Devil Fruits divine or demonic?

• Will Luffy remain Luffy?

As Elbaf approaches, Oda is no doubt setting the stage for answers.

Final Thoughts

Reddit has always been home to the wildest One Piece theories, but as we near the end, some of these "crazy ideas" feel more and more like prophecy. Elbaf may not just be the land of giants — it could be the final key to the mystery of the One Piece.

Whether you're Team "One Piece is a weapon" or Team "It's about the journey," one thing’s for sure: Elbaf will change everything.