Roronoa Zoro is one of the most formidable fighters in One Piece, known for his unmatched determination and loyalty. After his crushing defeat at the hands of Dracule Mihawk in the Baratie Arc, Zoro made a solemn vow to his captain, Monkey D. Luffy: he would never lose again until he became the world’s strongest swordsman. This promise defined his journey, pushing him to the absolute limits of his strength. But has Zoro truly kept his promise? Let's break down the instances where he has faced defeat since that fateful moment.
Understanding Zoro’s Promise
Zoro’s ultimate goal is to surpass Mihawk and claim the title of the strongest swordsman in the world. Because of this, some argue that his vow only applies to fights against swordsmen. However, if we take his words literally, it could mean that he vowed never to lose in combat, regardless of the opponent.
For this analysis, we’ll consider both perspectives and examine Zoro’s defeats against all types of opponents.
Instances Where Zoro Has Lost Since His Promise
1. Arlong (Arlong Park Arc)
While Zoro was already gravely injured from his battle with Mihawk, he still engaged Arlong in combat. Unfortunately, he was too weak to deal any significant damage and was ultimately overpowered. However, given that he was not at full strength, some might argue that this loss shouldn't count against his vow.
2. Enel (Skypiea Arc)
Zoro and the other Straw Hats faced off against Enel, the self-proclaimed god of Skypiea. Despite his incredible swordsmanship and combat skills, Zoro was no match for Enel's Logia-based Goro Goro no Mi (Lightning) abilities. Enel defeated him with relative ease, proving that raw power alone wasn’t enough to bridge the gap against a vastly superior Devil Fruit user.
3. Rob Lucci (Water 7 Arc - Non-Official Fight)
Though this wasn’t a full-fledged fight, Zoro was unable to stop Rob Lucci during their initial encounter in Water 7. When CP9 infiltrated Iceburg’s mansion, Zoro and his allies tried to fight back but were overwhelmed. Lucci incapacitated him before moving on to their primary objective. However, this was more of a scuffle rather than a formal duel, and Zoro later avenged the moment by playing a key role in the CP9 saga.
4. Kizaru (Sabaody Archipelago Arc)
During the events of the Sabaody Archipelago, the Straw Hats faced Admiral Kizaru, an opponent completely out of their league at the time. Zoro attempted to fight but was effortlessly subdued by Kizaru’s speed and light-based attacks. He was seconds away from being executed before Silvers Rayleigh intervened. This loss showcased just how far the Straw Hats still had to go before taking on the world’s strongest forces.
5. Yeti Cool Brothers (Punk Hazard Arc)
While traveling through Punk Hazard, Zoro, Sanji, and Brook were ambushed by the Yeti Cool Brothers. They used their size, strength, and environment to gain the upper hand, rendering Zoro unconscious for a brief period. This wasn’t a major defeat, but since Zoro was taken out of the fight, it technically counts as a loss.
6. Kaido & Big Mom (Wano Arc - Rooftop Battle)
Zoro was one of the key fighters in the battle against Kaido and Big Mom, standing alongside Luffy, Law, Kid, and Killer in the legendary rooftop battle of Onigashima. He put up an extraordinary fight, even managing to leave a lasting scar on Kaido—an incredible feat that only a handful of warriors had accomplished before. However, despite his efforts, he was ultimately overwhelmed by the sheer power of the Emperors and knocked out of the fight. Since this was a team battle, it’s debatable whether this counts as a true loss for Zoro individually, but it was still a fight in which he couldn’t claim victory.
Does Zoro’s Vow Still Hold?
Zoro’s promise was one of the most powerful moments in One Piece, and while he has faced defeats, most of them were against enemies who were either significantly stronger or not swordsmen. He has never lost a 1v1 duel against another swordsman since Baratie, maintaining the essence of his vow.
Additionally, in every fight where he was defeated, Zoro showed incredible growth afterward, proving that each loss was just a stepping stone toward becoming the world's strongest swordsman.
Conclusion
While Zoro has been overpowered multiple times since making his promise, the context of each battle is crucial. Most of his defeats were against overwhelming forces rather than direct sword fights, allowing some room for interpretation when it comes to his vow. Regardless, Zoro’s journey has been one of relentless improvement, and he remains one of the most dedicated and strongest warriors in One Piece.
Will he eventually achieve his dream of surpassing Mihawk? Only time will tell, but one thing is for sure—Zoro will never stop fighting to honor his promise to Luffy.
Do you think Zoro's vow still holds true, or do you believe his losses count against him? Let us know in the comments!
Follow on Twitter